|
JUDGING PET PEEVES
Every year after preliminary and finalist judging, the judges fill
out a feed back form for compliments, complaints and suggestions
not only regarding fair operations but also on the students and
the projects. The great news is that year after year new and current
judges are blown over by the continued quantity and quality of the
projects and students they see.
(If you're thinking of the difference between qualitative and quantitative
measurements right now then I suggest going for a walk or playing
in the snow).
There is room for improvement.
Here are some of the top responses we see:
There has been an increasing trend in the last several years of
"Bigger is Better" project boards. We no longer allow "flipbooks" on the display boards. The display must be a single layer. You need to get to the point on the display so the judges can quickly understand your work and findings. Save the details for your report.
- Don't have backboards that are "too tall". Judges
need to be able to comfortably read all of the text on your project
board. Just because you can have a board that's 78 tall (from
the table top) doesn't mean you should. And if you do, use a big enough font to read comfortably from a distance.
- Your project board is a technical brochure of your science project.
It presents your question, hypothesis, procedure, conclusion,
relevant data and results. Eye catching pictures and diagrams
where appropriate can highlight important points.
Abstracts
We're running out of ways to emphasize the importance of abstracts. They are required in advance of the Fair and reviewed by the judges before you arrive at the Fair.
The abstract of your project is an important essential element of
your display. It should be clear, concise and no more than 250 words.
It needs to be grammatically correct and free from spelling errors
(not that this is unimportant elsewhere for your project). Take
the extra time to write several drafts before deciding on a final
version. It's a very good idea to bring extra copies for the preliminary
and finalist judges. Don't worry about resume quality paper etc.,
simple xerox copies are sufficient.
|